Foursquare Mandamus and Convocation beside Doorly's 12, Doorly's 14 and R.L. Seale's 10 Year Old rums from Barbados

Award-Winning Rum: Foursquare's IWSC Record, and the Bottles You Can Buy


Looking for an award-winning rum you can actually buy? Start with Foursquare rum from Barbados. The IWSC's 2026 results news names Foursquare Mandamus 16 YO among five standout Foursquare bottles, in a year it says Foursquare won five Gold Outstanding medals in rum. Convocation 14 YO scored 95 points, a Gold, in 2025.

The IWSC (International Wine & Spirit Competition) also gave Foursquare its 2024 Rum Producer Trophy. Below is what the competition said each year, what the scores mean, and which bottle from the distillery suits which drinker.

Quick picks

Foursquare's IWSC record, year by year

Year What the IWSC said Bottle In our range?
2026 "Foursquare secured 5 Gold Outstanding medals in the rum category", and its standout expressions "included 5 top bottles from Foursquare" (IWSC, 12 June 2026) Mandamus 16 YO, alongside Penultimus 15 YO, Indomitas 15 YO, Supernum 21 YO and Epilogue 19 YO Mandamus, yes. The other four, no
2025 Convocation 14 YO Rum, Foursquare Rum Distillery, 95 points, in its list of Gold medal rums (IWSC, 2 July 2025) Convocation Yes
2024 Rum Producer Trophy, with Foursquare "securing four out of seven gold outstanding medals awarded" and six Golds (IWSC, 12 November 2024) A producer award, no single bottle Not applicable

One note on Mandamus. The IWSC's 2026 article lists the five Foursquare bottles as standouts next to its five Gold Outstanding line, but it does not tie a medal to each bottle by name. So we say Mandamus was named among the standouts, and we don't print a medal beside it.

What does Gold Outstanding mean at the IWSC?

IWSC medals follow a 100-point score. In its 2025 awards announcement, the IWSC gave the top two bands as Gold, 95 to 97 points, and Gold Outstanding, 98 to 100 (IWSC). Its FAQ adds that a Silver has been 90 to 94 points since 2019, and that "only the top-scoring drinks receive medals".

So Convocation's 95 is a Gold, at the bottom of that band, and a Gold Outstanding is the competition's top medal. A medal is a judging panel's view of one entry on the day, which is worth knowing before you read too much into it.

What is the Foursquare Exceptional Cask Selection?

Foursquare is a rum distillery in St Philip, Barbados. The IWSC says it was "established in 1996 by R L Seale & Co. Ltd.", a family firm that dates from the 1920s, and Difford's Guide says the Seales took over a disused sugar factory in 1995 before starting rum production in 1996. Richard Seale oversees distilling and blending.

The Exceptional Cask Selection (ECS) is the distillery's run of one-off releases, each given a "Mark" number and a name and, according to Foursquare's US brand company, hand-selected by Richard Seale. Each bottle's label sets out its cask type, age and distillation. Both bottles below read "Pot & Column Blend", rum from Foursquare's pot still and its Coffey column still blended together, then matured for well over a decade in two kinds of cask.

That is what these two bottles have in common: long ageing, two-cask maturation and blends of pot and column rum. It is also why every Mark tastes different. They are separate releases, not batches of one recipe.

Foursquare Mandamus (Exceptional Cask Selection Mark XXIX)

Bottle of Foursquare Mandamus Exceptional Cask Selection Barbados rum

Fact file
Producer Foursquare Rum Distillery, Barbados
Mark XXIX, released April 2025 (label)
Age 16 years
Casks Ex-bourbon barrels for 10 years, then ex-port pipes for six
Stills Pot and column blend
Strength 57%
IWSC Named among five standout Foursquare rums, 2026

Nose. Our tasting notes: dark and red fruit first, blackberry, tart plum, cherry and ripe pineapple, then sultanas, vanilla and caramel, ginger and a nutty edge of hazelnut and walnut.

Palate. Black cherry, raspberry and plum, with more sultanas and a touch of orange zest.

Finish. Long and toasty, gently smoky, with bitter chocolate, black tea, white pepper and a firm grip of oak.

How to drink it. Neat. Pour 30 ml, which is 1.3 standard drinks at 57%, leave it a few minutes, then add water a few drops at a time until it opens up.

Who it suits. A rum drinker who already enjoys aged, full-flavoured rum and wants a bottle the IWSC named among its 2026 standouts.

Foursquare Convocation (Exceptional Cask Selection Mark XXVIII)

Bottle of Foursquare Convocation Exceptional Cask Selection Barbados rum

Fact file
Producer Foursquare Rum Distillery, Barbados
Mark XXVIII, released October 2024 (label)
Age 14 years
Casks Two 14-year-old rums, one aged in ex-bourbon barrels and one in ex-Madeira casks
Stills Double-retort pot still and twin-column Coffey still
Strength 62%
IWSC Gold, 95 points, 2025

Nose. Our tasting notes: plump sultanas, pineapple and bright orange peel over butterscotch, with nutmeg, cinnamon and ginger.

Palate. Green pineapple, green banana, ripe plum, sultana and a little toffee.

Finish. Warm oak with plenty of grip, and dates, cinnamon and ginger that linger.

How to drink it. Neat, with water. At 62%, a 30 ml pour is 1.5 standard drinks, so measure it and add water gradually.

Who it suits. The rum lover who wants a bottle with an IWSC Gold to its name, or a gift for someone who collects the Marks.

The rest of the house: same distillery, no medal claimed

We found no IWSC result on the competition's own pages for these bottles, so we claim none. They come from the same distillery and are where most people should start.

Foursquare Magisterium is ECS Mark XXVI, a 16-year-old blend of three rums, all from the pot and column stills, matured in ex-bourbon and ex-oloroso sherry casks. Our listing finds woody aromas, dried fruit and caramel, then vanilla and spice. It is bottled at 58%, so a 30 ml pour is 1.4 standard drinks; measure it and add water gradually.

R.L. Seale's 10 Year Old carries the company name, which honours its founder, Reginald Leon Seale. It comes in a dark, asymmetrical bottle, and our listing describes it as matured in ex-bourbon casks. Its label reads 46%, so a 30 ml pour is 1.1 standard drinks. It is our pick for an everyday sipper from the distillery.

Doorly's is the house's other label. Difford's Guide says it is "a rum brand founded in the early 1920s by Martin Doorly" that R.L. Seale acquired in the early 1990s (Difford's Guide). Doorly's 12 Year Old's label reads "distilled, blended and bottled by R.L. Seale & Company Limited, Foursquare, St. Philip, Barbados". Doorly's 14 Year Old, at 48%, is a pot and column blend aged mostly in ex-bourbon with a share from Madeira casks, per Difford's. Doorly's XO is the one our listing calls complex, creamy and velvety. Doorly's 3 Year Old White, at 47%, is the mixing rum. Doorly's 14 and the 3 White are both above the usual 40%, so measure them with a jigger.

The distillery also makes Foursquare Spiced Rum (37.5%) and Foursquare Crisma, a 17% Barbados rum cream liqueur; our spiced rum guide covers both. Even Normandy borrows its casks: Christian Drouin's Pays d'Auge Foursquare 19 Year Old is a calvados finished in barrels that once held Foursquare rum, a bottle our French brandy guide puts in context.

Bar chart comparing the age in years of R.L. Seale's 10, Doorly's 12 and 14, Convocation 14, and Mandamus and Magisterium at 16

Which Foursquare should you buy?

  • To mix: Doorly's 3 Year Old White, the Daiquiri rum of the house.
  • To sip every day: R.L. Seale's 10 Year Old or Doorly's 12.
  • For a richer sipper: Doorly's 14, which also makes a rounder Mai Tai alongside a Jamaican rum.
  • The medal bottle for a rum lover: Convocation, with its 2025 Gold, or Mandamus, named among the 2026 standouts.

For a wider shelf, our guide to the best rum to buy in Australia covers other styles, and El Dorado, ranked does the same job for Guyana's heavier rums. If it is a present, see our rum gifts.

How much should a medal sway you?

Use it as a shortlist, not a verdict. An Exceptional Cask Selection Mark is a single release, so Convocation's Gold belongs to Convocation, Mark XXVIII. It does not carry over to the next Mark, to Magisterium or to Doorly's. Judges score what is in the glass on the day, and your taste may differ. If you are weighing medals across categories, our guide to award-winning bourbon applies the same rule to whiskey.

Foursquare rum FAQ

Is Foursquare rum good?

The IWSC thinks so. It gave Foursquare its 2024 Rum Producer Trophy, gave Convocation 14 YO a Gold with 95 points in 2025, and said Foursquare won five Gold Outstanding medals in rum in 2026. Taste is still personal, so start with R.L. Seale's 10 or Doorly's 12 before one of the high-strength Marks.

What is the Foursquare Exceptional Cask Selection?

It is Foursquare's series of one-off releases, each numbered as a "Mark" and given a name, such as Convocation (Mark XXVIII) and Mandamus (Mark XXIX). Each label states the cask type, age and distillation. Because every Mark is a separate rum, a medal for one Mark does not apply to another.

What does Gold Outstanding mean?

It is the IWSC's top medal band, for entries scoring 98 to 100 points. Gold covers 95 to 97 and Silver 90 to 94. The IWSC says only the top-scoring drinks receive medals. A medal reflects one judging panel's view of one entry, so read it alongside the tasting notes.

Who makes Doorly's rum?

R.L. Seale & Co., at the Foursquare Rum Distillery in St Philip, Barbados. Doorly's 12 Year Old's label says it is distilled, blended and bottled there. Difford's Guide says Martin Doorly founded the brand in the early 1920s and that R.L. Seale acquired it in the early 1990s.

Where to find them

Every bottle on this page is in our Foursquare rum range, with more from the island in Barbados rum and the whole shelf in all our rum. For the island's story, read the history of rum in Barbados, and for how the styles fit together, our guide to types of rum.