Mai Tai over crushed ice in a rocks glass, garnished with a lime shell and mint

Mai Tai Recipe: Trader Vic's 1944 Original, and the Rums to Use Today


A Mai Tai is aged rum, fresh lime, orange curaçao, orgeat (almond syrup) and a little sugar syrup, shaken with crushed ice. Trader Vic's 1944 Mai Tai recipe is 60 ml aged Jamaican rum, the juice of one lime (about 30 ml), 15 ml orange curaçao, 15 ml orgeat and 7.5 ml rock candy syrup. No pineapple juice.

Below are Vic's original and today's International Bartenders Association (IBA) spec side by side in millilitres, the method step by step, the argument over who invented it, and three ways to split the rum from our shelf.

Quick picks

What is in a Mai Tai?

Five ingredients and ice. Here is Trader Vic's original, as his company prints it on its history of the Mai Tai, beside the IBA's Mai Tai. Vic's ounces are converted at 30 ml to the ounce.

Ingredient Trader Vic's 1944 IBA today Our bottle
Rum 2 oz "17-year-old J. Wray Nephew Jamaican Rum" (60 ml) 30 ml amber Jamaican rum and 30 ml Martinique molasses rhum 30 ml Blackwell and 30 ml El Dorado 12 Year Old
Orange curaçao ½ oz "Holland De Kuyper Orange Curaçao" (15 ml) 15 ml orange curaçao 15 ml Gabriel Boudier Curaçao Triple Sec
Orgeat ½ oz "French Garnier Orgeat" (15 ml) 15 ml orgeat syrup (almond) 15 ml Vedrenne Sirop Orgeat
Sugar ¼ oz "Rock Candy Syrup" (7.5 ml) 7.5 ml simple syrup 7.5 ml St James Sucre de Canne
Lime "Juice from one whole lime" (about 30 ml) 30 ml fresh squeezed lime juice 30 ml fresh lime juice
Garnish Half the lime shell and a sprig of fresh mint Pineapple spear, mint leaves and lime peel The spent lime shell and mint

The four bottles for our Mai Tai: Blackwell Jamaican rum, El Dorado 12 Year Old, Gabriel Boudier orange curaçao and Vedrenne orgeat

Our version follows the IBA's two-rum spec. With Blackwell and El Dorado 12 (both 40%) and Boudier (38%), it is 2.3 standard drinks. Vic's original with 60 ml of Blackwell in place of his Jamaican rum is also 2.3.

Vic's "rock candy" syrup is, as Difford's Guide explains in its Mai Tai notes, an old name for a rich sugar syrup. Any sugar syrup works. We use St James Sucre de Canne, a liquid cane sugar.

How to make a Mai Tai, step by step

Mai Tai ingredients laid out before mixing: limes, almond syrup, orange peel, mint and crushed ice

  1. Chill the glass. Fill a double rocks glass with ice and water while you work, then tip it out.
  2. Juice the lime. Squeeze a fresh lime, measure 30 ml, and keep one spent half shell for the garnish.
  3. Measure everything into a shaker. 30 ml Blackwell, 30 ml El Dorado 12 Year Old, 15 ml orange curaçao, 15 ml orgeat, 7.5 ml sugar syrup and the lime juice.
  4. Add crushed ice and shake. A generous scoop of crushed ice, then shake hard and briefly. Vic's own account describes "a generous amount of shaved ice and vigorous shaking by hand".
  5. Pour it all in. Tip the drink and the ice together into the glass, as the IBA's "shake and pour" method does, rather than straining.
  6. Garnish. Vic's way is the spent lime shell and a sprig of fresh mint. The IBA adds a pineapple spear and lime peel. Either is right.

This one glass holds 60 ml of rum plus the curaçao, 2.3 standard drinks in all, so measure with a jigger rather than free pouring.

Who invented the Mai Tai?

Victor Bergeron, better known as Trader Vic, says he did. On his company's telling, in 1944 he was at the service bar of his Oakland restaurant when he took down a bottle of 17-year-old J. Wray Nephew Jamaican rum, added fresh lime, orange curaçao from Holland, a dash of rock candy syrup and "a dollop of French Orgeat", and shook it with shaved ice. He gave the first two to Ham and Carrie Guild, friends from Tahiti. Carrie tasted it and said "Mai Tai, Roa Ae", which, Vic wrote, means "Out of this World" and "The Best" in Tahitian. He named the drink Mai Tai.

The story is disputed. Difford's Guide notes that Ernest Raymond Beaumont-Gantt, then owner of the Hollywood bar Don the Beachcomber's, also laid claim to the drink, and it quotes Vic's revised Bartender's Guide of 1972: "I originated the Mai Tai." We don't settle the argument here. Vic's version, with its 1944 date and recipe, is the one his company still publishes, which is why it is the one we follow.

The drink travelled. In 1953, Trader Vic's says, the Matson Steamship Lines asked Vic to formalise drinks for the bars of its Royal Hawaiian, Moana and Surfrider hotels in Hawaii, and he took the Mai Tai with him.

What rum is best for a Mai Tai?

Vic built his on one aged Jamaican rum. Today's IBA spec splits the rum in two, 30 ml amber Jamaican and 30 ml Martinique molasses rhum, and Trader Vic's own current recipe uses the company's Royal Amber Rum. These are our three pairings, each 30 ml plus 30 ml in the recipe above.

Build Rums What it tastes like Standard drinks
Closest in spirit Blackwell and El Dorado 12 Year Old Jamaican depth with Demerara fruit and spice 2.3
Rounder Blackwell and Doorly's 14 Year Old (48%) Rounder, with oak and dried fruit 2.5
Modern and grassier Blackwell and J.M Rhum Agricole VSOP (43%) or Habitation St Etienne VO 4 Years (42%) Fresh cane and a drier finish 2.4

Why Blackwell? Difford's Guide says Blackwell is "distilled, blended and bottled by J.Wray & Nephew in Jamaica", a blend of pot and column still, molasses-based rums with no age statement. It is the same company named in Vic's recipe, though not the same rum. It is darker than the amber rum the IBA names, which suits a richer drink.

A note on agricole. Many modern recipes swap in a Martinique rhum agricole, made from fresh cane juice. The IBA is clear that this is not the original: "The Martinique molasses rum used by Trader Vic was not an Agricole Rhum but a type of 'rummy' from molasses." So treat the agricole build as a modern variation. Our rhum agricole guide explains the style, and the Martinique rum collection has the rest.

El Dorado's own version. El Dorado's Mai Tai, on its 8 Year Old page, uses 30 ml of the 8 Year Old and 20 ml of the 5 Year Old with fresh lime and orgeat. The rum alone is 1.6 standard drinks. Our guide to El Dorado, ranked covers every bottle, and our Demerara rum guide explains the style.

For a Barbados sipper instead of Doorly's 14, R.L. Seale's 10 Year Old (46% on its label) also works, at 2.5 standard drinks with Blackwell and Boudier. Our guide to Foursquare's award-winning rum covers both, and Barbados rum's history explains why the island matters.

Can you use dark rum in a Mai Tai?

Yes, if it is an aged dark rum. Blackwell is one. What you don't want is a spiced rum: the spice takes over from the lime and almond. If that is what is in your cupboard, our spiced rum guide has better uses for it.

What is orgeat?

Orgeat is, in Merriam-Webster's words, "a sweet almond-flavored nonalcoholic syrup used as a cocktail ingredient or food flavoring". The name is older than the almond: Merriam-Webster traces it through French to a Middle French word for a syrup made from a decoction of barley.

Bottle of Vedrenne orgeat almond syrup

Vedrenne makes its orgeat in Nuits-Saint-Georges in Burgundy. It pours opalescent white, smells of almond with a soft cereal note, and is alcohol-free. We keep ours in the fridge once opened. Because it is an almond syrup, check with guests who avoid nuts. The rest of the range is in our syrups, and if you like this style of drink, falernum is the lime and almond liqueur behind many other tiki builds.

Orange curaçao or triple sec?

Vic used an orange curaçao from Holland, and the IBA still names orange curaçao. Our three orange liqueurs all carry the word curaçao on the label or in the title, and they run from 38% to 25%:

The differences between curaçao, triple sec and Cointreau are a subject of their own, covered in orange curaçao or triple sec. More bottles are in our liqueurs.

Mai Tai vs Piña Colada

Both are tropical rum drinks, and that is where the likeness ends. A Mai Tai is lime and almond over aged rum, tart and nutty. A Piña Colada is white rum, coconut cream and pineapple, blended and creamy. If you want the coconut one, start with what coconut rum is, and for more long, cold drinks, see our summer cocktails.

Mai Tai FAQ

Does a Mai Tai have pineapple juice?

Not in the original. Trader Vic's 1944 recipe is aged rum, lime juice, orange curaçao, orgeat and rock candy syrup, with no pineapple or orange juice. The IBA's spec has no juice other than lime, though it garnishes with a pineapple spear. Versions made with pineapple or orange juice are variations on the original.

What rum is best for a Mai Tai?

An aged rum, ideally two. The IBA uses 30 ml amber Jamaican rum and 30 ml Martinique molasses rhum. We pair Blackwell, a Jamaican rum from J. Wray & Nephew, with El Dorado 12 Year Old for depth, or with Doorly's 14 Year Old for a rounder Barbados version. Avoid spiced rum.

Can I make a Mai Tai without orgeat?

Not really. Orgeat's almond is what makes a Mai Tai taste like one. Difford's Guide describes the drink as "basically a Daiquiri based on aged rum", with orange curaçao and orgeat adding flavour and sweetness. Leave the orgeat out and you have an aged-rum Daiquiri with orange liqueur, which is a different drink.

Is a Mai Tai a strong drink?

It holds 60 ml of rum plus an orange liqueur, so our recipe is 2.3 standard drinks in one glass, or 2.5 with Doorly's 14 at 48%. That is more than a single spirit and mixer. Measure with a jigger, serve it with food, and have water on the table.

Make it tonight

Pick two rums from our rum range, add a bottle of orgeat from our syrups, and you have everything for a proper Mai Tai recipe at home. For where each rum style comes from, our guide to types of rum is the place to start.